- Manaslu12–14 days · Larke La 5,106 m · no road between Jagat and Dharapani · restricted area with agency and guide requirement · simple lodges, stone camp before the pass · USD 1,000–1,900 in the package · a third of the people
- Annapurna8–14 days · Thorong La 5,416 m · road to Manang and from Muktinath, jeep entry points everywhere · guide requirement since 2023, permits obtainable yourself · good lodges, bakeries, Wi-Fi · USD 590–2,400 in the package · Tilicho Lake, Poon Hill as extras
- Who takes ManasluAnyone who already knows the Annapurna or does not want the road; anyone who puts culture and quiet above comfort; anyone with fourteen days who plans two rest days
- Who takes AnnapurnaAnyone going above 5,000 m for the first time; anyone who wants to shorten flexibly; anyone who wants to take in Tilicho Lake or Poon Hill; anyone with fewer than twelve days
- BothManaslu first, at Dharapani not into the jeep but on to Manang and over the Thorong La: 18–22 days, one set of permits for both conservation areas, the same agency
Landscape: a gorge and a valley against five climate zones
The Manaslu is a valley: five days in the Budhi Gandaki, first rice terraces and bananas, then a gorge with suspension bridges and cliff trails that Alpine Club of Himalaya calls “not for people with fear of heights”, then from Namrung the Tibetan Nubri with mani walls, monasteries and the eight-thousander at the head of the valley. There is one pass, and after it one day down. The Annapurna is broader: the Marsyangdi valley, Manang with its bakeries and Tilicho Lake as a side trip, the Thorong La as Nepal's highest trekking pass, then the desert of Mustang, Muktinath, the road to Jomsom and, if you want, Tatopani and Poon Hill. If you seek variety you find it on the Annapurna; if you want to get to know one valley completely, on the Manaslu. The mountain itself: Manaslu stands before you from Lho for three days; Annapurna I can hardly be seen from the circuit – but Annapurna II, III, IV, Gangapurna and Dhaulagiri can.
Road and crowds: the reason most people switch
On the Annapurna Circuit the track has reached Manang for years, and from Muktinath the rest to Jomsom is road; the packages therefore board the jeep at Chame or Dharapani and walk six to eight days instead of twenty. Those who walk share the trail with jeeps, dust and motorbikes. On the Manaslu the road ends at Machha Khola or Jagat, and between Jagat and Dharapani there is none – nine days on foot without an engine, only mules. The crowds: in high season several hundred people a day cross the Thorong La and a few dozen the Larke La; the lodges on the Manaslu are smaller, simpler and still full in October because there are so few. Dharmasala before the pass has two stone huts with dormitories and tents; Thorong Phedi has lodges with rooms and a High Camp above. If you want comfort, take the Annapurna; if you see the reason for the trek in the absence of a road, the Manaslu – as long as the road has not reached Jagat, which it will within a few years.

